|
Post by topii on Jan 27, 2009 13:03:39 GMT 1
I cant believe Tony is bad.. Yh he done some bad things but only because he was angry with the goverment like everyone else had saud here. I think when he saw its getting too bad his conscience kicked in. I mean probably killing Latham didnt seem like such a horrible thing to do for Tony, but helping killing hundreds of american was too much for him. I just canr believe that he is fooling Chloe and Bill and willing to kill all of these people...
|
|
|
Post by smitten on Jan 27, 2009 21:22:29 GMT 1
I have more reason to think Tony might be bad than I did in season 1 to think Nina might be bad. But I do like this new Tony, and I hope he's good, I hope he lives. He's still Tony, but darker, less shaven. More Jack-ish. Whether or not I buy that he's back, I'm glad that he is! It's things like he and Jack need so few words together - one does something and the other just understands. They pick up on each other so quickly - I like that dynamic.
|
|
|
Post by topii on Jan 27, 2009 21:46:23 GMT 1
He's still Tony, but darker, less shaven. More Jack-ish. Whether or not I buy that he's back,. Thats what I love about this show so much!! The characters are really changing and they have a reason to and you can see the change on the great actors! Im watching the 1st season at the moment and you can see a huge change between Jack back then and now, its really amazing! You can see it on Tony aswell.
|
|
|
Post by smitten on Feb 4, 2009 13:39:05 GMT 1
13:00-14:00 revealed more about how Tony ended up with Emerson OK, so now we can move on to up to 2pm, and I presume Evil's talking about the conversation in the van? I liked how this happened. I'm never sure Emerson trusted Jack, he picked up on Jack's unease, and Jack found a natural outlet for what was bothering him. But, this business with Henderson bothers me. First of all, it's bollocks to suggest that he deliberately missed an artery. These writers clearly know nothing about anatomy, and they should just stay well away from it. You can't tell, when you stick a needle in someone, where the tip is. Arteries, veins, even the major ones, will be in different places in different people. You just can't be that accurate. Worse than that, I'm having trouble with Henderson's motivation. At the time he wanted to disable Tony so that he could escape. It didn't seem to matter to him much whether Tony lived or died, and he only had a short time to act. So, was Henderson in league with Emerson who was keeping tabs on Tony? That's the implication. Now it gets worse. If Henderson was in league with Emerson (and Henderson had Michelle killed) then why on earth would Tony hook up with Emerson? I can buy Tony being angry with the government, I can buy him becoming an anarchist and doing some form of 'bad things'. But I can't buy him chumming about with the crowd that killed Michelle. Next comes what Tony says about it. It was a pretty intense conversation, talking about Tony in his presence, then Tony spoke. But Carlos spoke so softly, I'll be buggered if I can make out a word he says. Something about brothers. Can anyone help? Or does anyone have a solution to me Henderson/Emerson problem?
|
|